Bookmark and Share

Printer-friendly versionPDF version
Average: 3.6 (5 votes)

Bayard v. Singleton

by Andy Hollins, 2006

See also: Bayard v. Singleton (Research Branch, N.C. Office of Archives and History)

Bayard v. Singleton was possibly the first legal decision in the United States in which a court nullified a law because it was found to be unconstitutional. During the American Revolution the government confiscated the land of Loyalists to raise money for the war. People whose land was seized were those who refused to swear an oath of allegiance to North Carolina, maintaining their loyalty to Great Britain instead. Although born in America, Samuel Cornell, a Loyalist, lost his land when it was confiscated by North Carolina. It was later purchased in part by Spyres Singleton. In 1786 Cornell's daughter, Elizabeth Cornell Bayard, to whom Cornell had willed this property, sued Singleton for the portion of her father's property that had been left to her. In response, Singleton's attorneys cited a law passed by the North Carolina legislature in 1785 that said that those who held land purchased under the state's Confiscation Acts of 1777 and 1779 could not be sued for the return of their land.

After lengthy consideration, the state court-composed of Judges Samuel Ashe, Samuel Spencer, and John Williams-citing the state constitution, declared that the 1785 act was unconstitutional and those whose property had been seized were entitled to a trial by jury. Although Singleton was able to keep the land based on the state Confiscation Acts, the significance of the case resulted from the court's overruling of an established act of the legislature. This ruling by the court was an early example of the system of checks and balances vital to the new American democracy. Bayard v. Singleton set a precedent for judicial review, as applied by the U.S. Supreme Court in the 1803 case of Marbury v. Madison.

Update from N.C. Government & Heritage Library staff: 

Elizabeth Bayard was represented in her suit by future governors Samuel Johnston and William R. Davie. Singleton retained the services of former governor Abner Nash and future U.S. Supreme Court Justice Alfred Moore.

Biographies for these individuals can be found in NCpedia.

References:

Lindley S. Butler and Alan D. Watson, eds., The North Carolina Experience: An Interpretive and Documentary History (1984).

Don Higginbotham, "James Iredell's Efforts to Preserve the British Empire," NCHR 49 (1972).

Quinton Holton, "History of the Case of Bayard v. Singleton" (M.A. thesis, UNC-Chapel Hill, 1948).

Additional Resources:

"Bayard V. Singleton." NC Highway Historical Marker C-20, North Carolina Highway Historical Marker Program, N.C. Office of Archives & History: http://www.ncmarkers.com/Markers.aspx?sp=Markers&k=Markers&sv=C-20 (accessed December 4, 2012).

Martin's Reports. p.42-49. http://statelibrary.ncdcr.gov/ghl/themes/images/january/bayard.pdf (accessed December 4, 2012).

Miskimon, "An N.C. precedent for judicial review." NewsObserver.com. July 4, 2012http://www.newsobserver.com/2012/07/04/2177462/an-nc-precedent-for-judicial-review.html (accessed December 4, 2012).

Authors: 

Comments

Comment: 

The article omits the lawyers in the case - notably Abner Nash and Alfred Moore. This is NC history without the history. You also miss the opportunity to cross reference this article to articles about the two famous politicians and lawyers. Shame on you.

Comment: 

Dear Hugh,

Thank you for visiting NCpedia and taking time to leave your comment and reaction to the article.

I'm sorry you found the entry missing information. I have added an addendum to the entry to include the lawyers who represented Elizabeth Bayard and Spyres Singleton.  I have also added an additional entry on the court case which comes from the Research Branch at the N.C. Office of Archives and History. You can find it in NCpedia at: http://ncpedia.org/bayard-v-singleton-judicial-precedent.

I hope this additional information and article help and thank you for alerting us to the omission.

Best wishes,

Kelly Agan, NC Government & Heritage Library

Add a comment

PLEASE NOTE: NCpedia will not publish personal contact information in comments, questions, or responses. If you would like a reply by email, please note thats some email servers are blocked from accepting messages from outside email servers or domains. These often include student email addresses from public school email accounts. If you prefer not to leave an email address, check back at your NCpedia comment for a reply. Please allow one business day for replies from NCpedia. Complete guidelines are available at http://ncpedia.org/comments.

Copyright notice

This article is from the Encyclopedia of North Carolina edited by William S. Powell. Copyright © 2006 by the University of North Carolina Press. Used by permission of the publisher. For personal use and not for further distribution. Please submit permission requests for other use directly to the publisher.

Grey Squirrel - Click me to return to the top of the page